# Bulletin of the American Physical Society

# 2013 Annual Fall Meeting of the APS Prairie Section

## Volume 58, Number 15

## Thursday–Saturday, November 7–9, 2013; Columbia, Missouri

### Session F1: Poster Session (5:40 - 7:00 PM)

5:40 PM,
Friday, November 8, 2013

Memorial Union
Room: Mark Twain

Chair: Carlos Wexler, University of Missouri

Abstract ID: BAPS.2013.PSF.F1.33

### Abstract: F1.00033 : Opposite Thought Experiment

Preview Abstract
MathJax **On** | Off Abstract

#### Author:

Florentin Smarandache

(University of New Mexico)

Let's consider the opposite case: when we have the astronaut measures the elapse interval time of the event on the earth. It is alike the rocket stands still and the Earth is moving in the opposite direction with speed v. The observer on earth measures the elapsed proper time of the event on earth, $\Delta t_{E} '$ The elapsed non-proper time of the event on earth as measured by the astronaut is $\Delta t_{E} $. Using the same calculations, with $\Delta t_{E} '$ and $\Delta t_{E} $as the elapsed proper and respectively non-proper time of the event on earth as measured by the observer on earth and respectively by the astronaut, we get: $\Delta t_{E} =\frac{\Delta t'_{E} }{\sqrt {1-\frac{v^{2}}{c^{2}}} }$. Therefore the time dilation is measured by the astronaut in the rocket. This result is contradictory with the time dilation on the earth from the previous thought experiment. But, according to Einstein's Thought Experiment with the Light Clocks, one has: $\Delta t=\frac{\Delta t'}{\sqrt {1-\frac{v^{2}}{c^{2}}} }$, where $\Delta t$ is the elapsed time interval in the rocket as measured by the observer on earth, and $\Delta t'$ is the elapsed time interval in the rocket, as measured by the astronaut. Then who is right, the observer on earth or the astronaut? Where is really the time dilation: on earth or in the rocket? The advocates of special theory of relativity say that there is no answer to this question. They pretend that's okay. But what kind of theories are those that have undecidable propositions? Incomplete or inconsistent ones!

To cite this abstract, use the following reference: http://meetings.aps.org/link/BAPS.2013.PSF.F1.33

## Follow Us |
## Engage
Become an APS Member |
## My APS
Renew Membership |
## Information for |
## About APSThe American Physical Society (APS) is a non-profit membership organization working to advance the knowledge of physics. |

© 2017 American Physical Society
| All rights reserved | Terms of Use
| Contact Us

**Headquarters**
1 Physics Ellipse, College Park, MD 20740-3844
(301) 209-3200

**Editorial Office**
1 Research Road, Ridge, NY 11961-2701
(631) 591-4000

**Office of Public Affairs**
529 14th St NW, Suite 1050, Washington, D.C. 20045-2001
(202) 662-8700